Siri AI and the EU
I prefer more open systems, so of course I lean toward supporting the EU’s DMA. Third-party marketplaces on iOS represent real progress that wouldn’t have happened without regulation. But what about Siri AI? It is not coming to the EU because Apple doesn’t trust other developers with access to user data via third-party App Intents.
It struck me today what a contrast this is with the rest of the AI world, increasingly connected via MCP. Imagine if Gmail was only accessible to AI on Android phones. If Teams was only accessible from a Windows Surface laptop. That is the kind of environment Apple’s policies create, with data locked into silos and monopolies free to leverage their existing strengths into dominance of new technologies too.
No thanks. Just as I should be able to sideload an app onto my own phone, I should be able to choose whether ChatGPT can access my iMessage history. The world is not going to come crashing down by giving users control of their own data.
Ironically, Apple’s approach to AI — driven by a well-meaning but almost fanatical devotion to privacy — is also going to cripple their ability to build a truly universal Siri that works across even their own platforms. That leaves a small opening for competition.
Apple is betting that Siri AI will be perfect for most iPhone users, and they’re probably right. But it’s a fairly limited vision that, while safe for users, forecloses most of the potential upside of truly powerful AI to work on users’ behalf in the future.