The fall of Jensen Huang

The news lately around Nvidia is fascinating. My feelings have drifted back and forth. Initially I could not believe that Jensen Huang would resign. Last night I also watched a couple DealBook interviews with people who actually knew him, and I’ve read a bunch of stories from employees.

There was a lot in Ben Thompson’s post this week about Jensen’s fall. On the American Dream:

Huang was sent to America as a nine year old who didn’t speak a lick of English, and somehow ended up at a boarding school in rural Kentucky for misbehaving youth, where he would trade help on homework for protection from bullies. From there he went to a state school in Oregon, became an engineer, before famously ending up at a Denny’s diner where he and his co-founders decided to start Nvidia.

Over the weekend, I re-read the October 29 and 30 articles from the NYT and WSJ that set off the “Alice Huang is a spy” narrative. Knowing what we know now, the story looks weaker, except for the details on Megaspeed’s apparent hustle to skirt export control laws.

Ben covered that too:

Nvidia’s immediate reaction to those initial controls, which restricted exports based on interconnect speed, was to immediately release the A800 in China, which was an A100 with a third of its interconnects disabled. That set the tone for the conflict that I believe was the true cause of Huang’s downfall: Huang strenuously disagreed with the various iterations of the chip ban, and Nvidia only bothered to do the bare minimum to abide by the letter of the law, never the spirit.

The sentiment from tech folks seems largely divided based on what filter bubbles you’re spending your online social time in. For some people, Jensen is a billionaire with a stack of recent poor choices and he deserves little empathy. For others, Jensen is an irreplaceable leader who should not have resigned until there was an investigation.

I haven’t bought into the conspiracy theories that this was a coordinated hit job… But I think it was a hit to AI. It’s convenient but perhaps just coincidental timing for Anthropic’s IPO this week. Of all the frontier labs, Anthropic is the most against open source and the open weight models that Jensen advocated for.

Could Jensen make a comeback? It seems unlikely, and yet this whole saga is uncharted territory, not directly comparable to other founders who have left and then returned to their companies.

Jensen wrote a long post on X about all of this. The part about a potential return:

Since my departure, I’ve seen an outpouring of calls from NVIDIA’s employees, investors, business partners, and customers for me to return as CEO. Many continue to reach out to me directly as the company navigates complex technology, market, competitive, and geopolitical dynamics. NVIDIA is a once-in-a-generation company. If the Board of Directors decides that my return is in the best interest of our shareholders, our employees, the company, and America, I would be honored to answer these calls and return as CEO.

In the earnings call, board chairman Harvey Jones dismissed that idea:

Jensen Huang voluntarily resigned his positions as president, CEO, and board member. The Nvidia board unanimously accepted his resignation and does not intend to reinstate Jensen as CEO.

Betting market Kalshi currently has Jensen as the next CEO at 10%. It has fallen from 14% when I first started drafting thoughts for this post a few days ago. Seems about right.

I have mixed feelings about Jensen’s fall. He made mistakes and it’s appropriate to have accountability for that. But also, I like to see founder-led companies that aren’t afraid to have strong opinions. That is often how progress is made. Interesting people make for interesting companies. (Interesting people can also bring division and chaos, but I don’t think Jensen was like that.)

Nvidia will now become yet another boring company. They will slowly bleed talent. $4 trillion companies don’t vanish, but I think we’re clearly looking at Nvidia at a height of success that it won’t return to.

Manton Reece @manton