The moat is ambition

Anthropic’s IPO is live. John Gruber had a short post today, making two points that I want to comment on:

(a) there is no permanent moat around LLM technology, only a temporary one at the frontier that’s fueled by an enormous bubble pumped up by Jensen Huang at Nvidia

While I agree it’s not a “permanent” moat — what lead in technology is actually permanent? — I think this sells short the moat. A lead can compound: it attracts engineers and lets a company take bets its competitors can’t. I still believe what I blogged a few months ago. It’s possible this all falls apart, but it’s also possible we have undervalued the advances that AI will bring. I know that sounds a little crazy given the hype.

The moat isn’t just the gap between (for example) Siri AI and GPT-6.2 Astra, which solved open math problems, or the internal Claude models that Anthropic is putting to work in health and science. The moat is ambition. The moat is playing a completely different game. Some companies want to use AI to make the world significantly better, even acknowledging the risks, and some companies want to charge more for iCloud+.

To balance that cheap shot, I will say that the Apple Watch has been a big step forward for people’s health.

Perhaps I’ve become too cynical on one side, and too AI-pilled on the other. Even though society has been burned by technology in the last decade, especially social media and its impact on mental health, I still want to believe that tomorrow will be better and worth striving for. My complaints about Twitter and Facebook would’ve been hollow words without also starting Micro.blog.

(b) even if I’m wrong on the first part, this particular cult of religious freaks and weirdos isn’t fit to lead a public company

This part of John’s post I won’t argue with. While there’s potential for Anthropic to do good, there’s also something unnerving about how they approach it. It’s a dangerous path to go down when you start attributing consciousness to AI models. When you believe only you can be trusted to create the machine god that we will all then have to put our own trust in. A company with that mindset should not accumulate too much power.

Manton Reece @manton